ElderShield vs CareShield Life: What’s the Real Diff?

This post breaks down the crucial differences between ElderShield vs CareShield Life to help you understand what Singapore’s national long-term care schemes mean for your financial future.

ElderShield vs CareShield: Similarities

Think of ElderShield as the well-meaning older sibling and CareShield Life as the younger, more robust successor. The government designed both national insurance schemes to provide Singaporeans with a financial cushion should they become severely disabled and require long-term care.

The core similarity lies in their activation trigger: a person must be unable to perform at least 3 out of 6 Activities of Daily Living (ADLs). These are basic self-care tasks: 1) Washing, 2) Dressing, 3) Feeding, 4) Toileting, 5) Walking or moving around, 6) Transferring from a bed to a chair

However, this is where the similarities largely end. The significant differences in their coverage, payouts, and overall structure are crucial to understand.

ElderShield vs CareShield: Key Differences

Let’s get down to the nitty-gritty. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for your long-term care planning.

1. Who is Covered? A Generational Divide

The most straightforward difference between ElderShield and CareShield Life is who they cover.

1. ElderShield: The government made this scheme the default for Singaporeans and Permanent Residents (PRs) born in 1979 or earlier. It automatically enrolled them at age 40, but individuals had the option to opt-out. The government no longer accepts new applications for ElderShield.
2. CareShield Life: This is the mandatory national long-term care insurance for all Singaporeans and PRs born in 1980 or later. The scheme automatically enrols you when you turn age 30.

Note: If you were born 1979 or earlier, you have the option to switch from ElderShield to CareShield Life.

2. Payouts: Comparing Financial Support

Here’s where the differences become even more pronounced.

2.1 Payout Amount

1. ElderShield: Provides fixed cash payouts of $300 per month for up to 60 months (ElderShield 300) or $400 per month for up to 72 months (ElderShield 400).
2. CareShield Life: Payouts start at $600 per month in 2020 and increase 2% (currently) annually until age 67 or when a successful claim is made, whichever is earlier. Once the first payout has been made, the payout amount is locked in.

2.2. Payout Duration

1. ElderShield: Payouts are limited to a maximum of 60 months (5 years) for ElderShield 300 or 72 months (6 years) for ElderShield 400. Coverage continues for life once all premiums are completed at age 65.
2. CareShield Life: Provides lifetime cash payouts for as long as the severe disability persists. This offers much better protection compared to the 6-year limit under ElderShield, especially since about 3 in 10 severely disabled Singapore residents could remain in severe disability for 10 years or more.

3. Premiums: The Cost of ElderShield vs CareShield

Naturally, better benefits come with higher premiums.

1. ElderShield: Premiums are fixed based on your age of entry, and you pay them annually until age 65. You can pay your premiums fully using your MediSave.
2. CareShield Life: You pay premiums from age 30 until age 67. The premiums are not fixed and will increase over time. However, the government provides various subsidies to help keep them affordable. Like ElderShield, you can pay premiums fully via MediSave.

Should You Stick with ElderShield or Make the Switch?

This is the million-dollar question for those born in 1979 or earlier. While ElderShield provides a basic level of protection, CareShield Life’s lifetime and increasing payouts offer a much more robust safety net against the rising costs of long-term care.

The Case for Upgrading to CareShield Life

1. Lifelong Peace of Mind: CareShield Life’s lifetime payout feature eliminates the worry of financial support running out after a few years.
2. Inflation Protection: The current 2% p.a. increasing payouts help ensure that the financial assistance you receive keeps pace with the rising costs of healthcare and caregiving.
3. Government Subsidies: The government offers incentives and subsidies to encourage older Singaporeans to join CareShield Life, making it more affordable.

ElderShield vs CareShield Life: Key Differences and Benefits

Before making the switch, it’s important to understand the advantages of CareShield Life over ElderShield:

Making the Switch from Eldershield to CareShield Life

The upgrading process is straightforward. You can apply to join CareShield Life through the official website. The government will consider the ElderShield premiums you have already paid when calculating your CareShield Life premiums.

The Role of ElderShield/CareShield Supplements (“Upgrades”)

Both ElderShield and CareShield Life provide a basic level of financial protection. However, the monthly payouts may not be sufficient to cover the full cost of long-term care, which can include hiring a domestic helper, nursing home fees, or specialized therapy.

This is where supplementary plans from private insurers come in. You can purchase these plans to enhance your coverage, which can offer benefits such as:

1. Higher monthly payouts
2. A lower disability threshold (e.g., payouts upon the inability to perform just 1 or 2 ADLs)
3. Lump-sum benefits

The Final Word on ElderShield vs CareShield

Ultimately, the choice between the two schemes depends on your desired level of financial security, with CareShield Life offering more comprehensive, lifelong protection against long-term care costs.

Need Personalised Advice?

Get a free, no-obligation comparison of your options. Contact us or log in with Singpass to learn more.